Ivan Cleary Faces Backlash After Penrith Panthers’ Shocking Loss to Sydney Roosters in Round 2
Penrith Panthers head coach Ivan Cleary and captain Isaah Yeo are at the center of a heated controversy following their side’s unexpected loss to the Sydney Roosters in Round 2 of the 2025 NRL Premiership season. The Panthers, who were seen as heavy favorites heading into the match, suffered a stunning defeat that left both players and fans stunned, raising more questions than answers in the post-match media conference.
The game, played at the Panthers’ home ground, was touted as a sure win for the defending premiers, who had come into the new season with high expectations. However, in what many have described as a “classic upset,” the Roosters dominated the game with a 38-32 victory, leaving the Panthers in a state of disbelief. The loss is their second of the season, and while early losses are not uncommon in the NRL, this particular defeat has stirred up intense frustration, especially among the fans and media.
Cleary and Yeo, normally seen as a composed and well-prepared leadership duo, were visibly rattled in the post-game press conference. When questioned about the team’s poor performance, both struggled to provide clear, logical explanations for what had gone wrong. Fans who were hoping for insights into the tactical errors or player performances were left disappointed by the lack of constructive feedback.
“There’s no excuse for that,” Cleary said, his voice betraying a hint of frustration as he tried to explain the loss. “We just didn’t execute the way we know we can. We need to regroup, and there’s a lot of work to do.”
However, when pushed further on specific areas of concern – such as the team’s discipline, defensive lapses, and their failure to capitalize on attacking opportunities – Cleary became noticeably defensive. “It’s just one of those things,” he continued. “We have to move on and get ready for next week.”
Isaah Yeo, who is known for his leadership and calm demeanor, was equally unconvincing when pressed about the team’s failure to stick to the game plan. “It’s a tough loss, and we’ll be looking at it during the week,” Yeo said, avoiding direct answers to questions about the team’s breakdowns on both ends of the field. “We’ll review it and take it from there.”
This lack of clarity sparked a wave of anger and confusion among the fans, who had hoped to hear a more in-depth analysis from the pair. Social media platforms exploded with criticism, with many fans expressing their discontent about the team’s performance and the inadequate responses from their coach and captain.
“Is that it? A vague excuse and a ‘we’ll review it’?” one fan tweeted. “The team looks unprepared, and all we get is empty talk. Where’s the leadership, Ivan?”
Others felt that Cleary and Yeo were not taking enough responsibility for the team’s underperformance. “Cleary and Yeo need to do better. As leaders, they should be setting the example, not dodging questions,” another fan wrote on social media. “The Panthers can’t just rely on talent alone – they need strategy and better preparation.”
The lack of a detailed game analysis also led to speculation about the team’s internal dynamics. Some have suggested that the Panthers are still adjusting to the loss of several key players during the off-season, while others have pointed to possible tactical issues that have not been addressed.
As for the match itself, the Roosters executed their game plan with clinical precision. Their forwards dominated the middle, and their backs exploited gaps in the Penrith defense, particularly during the second half when the Panthers seemed to lose their composure. A standout performance from Roosters halfback Luke Keary, who orchestrated the attack with poise, proved pivotal in breaking down Penrith’s usually solid defense.
Despite the disappointing loss, Cleary’s position as coach is not immediately under threat, but the pressure is mounting. The Panthers have long been the benchmark of NRL excellence, and with expectations high for the 2025 season, any slip-ups are magnified.
While the coach and captain have remained adamant that the loss is a learning experience, the angry reactions from fans suggest that the road to redemption won’t be an easy one. Cleary and Yeo will need to provide more than vague platitudes in the coming weeks if they are to quell the growing frustration among the fanbase and restore confidence in their title aspirations.
As the team heads into the coming rounds, all eyes will be on the Panthers to see if they can bounce back from this shock loss, both on and off the field. The fans are demanding answers, and with their premiership hopes on the line, Cleary and his squad must deliver.
Leave a Reply